Proposed Criteria: Middle Kingdom A&S Division I

As many of you know, the Middle Kingdom is currently working on updating the criteria for A&S competitions. I’m the team lead for Division I, which includes the performing and literary arts.

It is very important that the new criteria work well for the people who plan to enter these categories in A&S fairs. So Midrealm performing and literary artists, we need your feedback!

As categories become available for public commentary, I’ll post links to them here. Please read and comment on any that are of interest to you.

Categories in Division I

2 thoughts on “Proposed Criteria: Middle Kingdom A&S Division I

  1. I think you should make more explicit the distinction between “medieval” and “renaissance” music, with a date cutoff as you did to separate 15C from 16C dance. 1500 would be appropriate, in my opinion, but “renaissance” is a very poorly defined term in musicology and most “renaissance music” textbooks say in the foreword that the phrase lacks meaning.

    I must say I’m impressed with your categories, as a rule!

    Liked by 1 person

  2. I’d add a category (or add onto a category) for arrangement of music from a period manuscript. This is not composition, and should not include performance. For instance, I usually arrange music from 16th c. lute and choir manuscript sources, rewriting difficult to access tabs and staffs into modern notation for the modern musician. I would broadly divide the sources into neumes, ligatures, and Elizabethan notations. An example would be the death song of Charlemagne, written by his own personal bard, in neumes, which drove me absolutely nuts until I figured out it was a bagpipe piece. It became one of my best after I added the drone. A fair amount of organ pieces from the 1400’s written in ligatures could be the source for cat 2, and the Elizabethan songbooks are legion.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s